This week we’ve got another one of my “this” VERSUS “that” posts, but I’m trying out the “>” (greater than) sign instead of the “Vs”.
I find contrasting two opposing ideas or viewpoints perfectly conducive to this blog format, so I continually return to it.
There’s a certain satisfaction in starting with one aspect of something and then immediately looking at the other side for confirmation of what you’ve learned, by seeing an opposing view.
I’ll also share the catalyst for the idea for this blog, because that context is often germane to the discussion.
And it’s no surprise that once again, a social media post from a colleague is at the origin of this week’s piece.
Great Insights from LinkedIn Connections
Back in June, on LinkedIn, friend and colleague Russell Haworth, of Family Business Podcast fame, had uploaded one of his informative videos. I watched it and made a comment, then another colleague replied to my comment, and voilà, here we are with a blog post.
Haworth’s video presented a modified version of the Three Circle Model, directed specifically at advisors to family businesses, and he noted that some of the family’s advisors from the more technical side of planning could actually also be good at understanding and working with family members on the emotional side of things too.
I added that in cases where those advisors had been involved in crafting the plans with the parents’ generation only, even if they were comfortable with the family side, they might still be conflicted, because they could be in a position of “selling” their plans, as a sort of “fait accompli” to the rising generation.
When you’ve had a huge hand in putting the plan together as an advisor, it can be difficult to then be open to the criticisms that may arise when the plan is then shared with those for whom it was prepared.
A reply form another colleague followed up my idea of getting the offspring involved before the plans were finalized, stating that when the rising generation are involved in the planning, they’ll actually “buy in” to the plans, while in the alternative scenario, they’re “being sold”.
BANG! There It Is!
Rarely has a blog idea come to me so clearly. (Thanks, Daniel).
As someone who’s skin begins to crawl at the first hint of feeling like I am “being sold”, this resonated with me immediately.
It also had me flash back to this blog from a few years back where the idea was also laid out for readers. That post included this quote:
“Plans that are about us, but don’t include us, are not for us”.
And so here we are again, with a familiar subject on the table, the one where a certain group of people are organizing and leading a process where they’re making plans that ultimately affect a group of people that does not include them, but they choose to do this without involving the people who will be most directly affected.
Umm, OK, Thanks (?)
As parents of young children, it’s all well and good to meet with your lawyer to draft a will to figure out and decide what will happen in case you die an untimely death, without involving those young children.
But, when those “children” become adults, and therefore now become better described as “former children”, or better yet, “offspring”, then making plans FOR them, without consulting them, becomes a recipe for problems.
Oh, and stating that you’re doing this because that’s the way your parents handled things won’t necessarily fly either (not with me, and not with your offspring either).
Your parents likely had you sitting in the back seat of their car without a seatbelt too.
If there’s any chance that the reaction from the beneficiaries of your planning might be “Umm, OK, Thanks (?)”, then you probably didn’t make enough of an effort to involve them in the process.
Being Involved = Buying In
Everyone can understand that people who are involved in the creation of a plan will be more likely to “buy in” to the result than those who simply have things handed down to them from above.
This is not rocket science.
Yes, it’s more complicated and will take longer. But it is well worth the extra effort. If they feel like they’re “being sold”, good luck.